For this week’s Zero Star Reviews post, we’ll go into the wayback machine to take a look at what some critics had to say about some literary classics, a couple of cinematic masterpieces, and one of the best albums of the 1980s.
ALICE’S ADVENTURES IN WONDERLAND, LEWIS CARROLL (1865)
Full of “loops and ties, and loose threads, and entanglements, and inconsistencies, and passages which lead to nothing.”
“We fancy that any real child might be more puzzled than enchanted by this stiff, over-wrought story.”
The Athenaeum, Dec. 16, 1865
FRANKENSTEIN, MARY SHELLEY (1818)
“Our readers will guess from this summary, what a tissue of horrible and disgusting absurdity this work presents…The dreams of insanity are embodied in the strong and striking language of the insane, and the author, notwithstanding the rationality of his preface, often leaves us in doubt whether he is not as mad as his hero.” (Mary Shelley is a woman.)
“Our taste and our judgment alike revolt at this kind of writeing, and the greater the ability with which it may be executed the worse it is — it inculcates no lesson of conduct, manners, or morality; it cannot mend, and will not even amuse its readers, unless their taste have been deplorably vitiated — it fatogues the feelings without interesting the understanding; it gratuitously harasses the heart, and wantonly adds to the store, already too great, of painful sensations…leaving the wearied reader, after a struggle between laughter and loathing, in doubt whether the head or the heart of the author be the most diseased.”
Quarterly Review, Vol. 18, No. 36, Jan. 1818
DR. STRANGELOVE (1964)
The film is “beyond any question the most shattering sick joke I’ve ever come across.” He objects to its “discredit and even contempt for our whole defense establishment.” On the closing bomb sequence: “Somehow, to me, it isn’t funny. It is malefic and sick.” - Bosley Crowther, The New York Times, Jan. 30, 1964
DUMB AND DUMBER (1994)
An execrable catalogue of doody jokes, 'Dumb and Dumber' is an abominable, abdominal comedy... Suffice to say the future doesn't look bright for the Farrellys." Washington Post, Dec. 16, 1994
10,000 MANIACS: IN MY TRIBE (1988)
"A group so embued (sic) with it's (sic) own sense of self-worth they leave you little room to discover their worth for yourself...one step away from the garage...Natalie can only infer, scold and meekly plead. It’s weak.” Creem, Jan. 1988









